{
  "schema_version": 2,
  "kind": "commonworld_editorial_review_contract",
  "current_as_of": "2026-07-31",
  "statuses": [
    "submitted",
    "needs_information",
    "under_review",
    "accepted",
    "rejected",
    "withdrawn",
    "published",
    "superseded"
  ],
  "transitions": {
    "submitted": [
      "needs_information",
      "under_review",
      "withdrawn"
    ],
    "needs_information": [
      "submitted",
      "under_review",
      "rejected",
      "withdrawn"
    ],
    "under_review": [
      "needs_information",
      "accepted",
      "rejected",
      "withdrawn"
    ],
    "accepted": [
      "published",
      "superseded"
    ],
    "published": [
      "superseded"
    ],
    "rejected": [],
    "withdrawn": [],
    "superseded": []
  },
  "review_checks": [
    "project_exists",
    "official_or_primary_near_source",
    "commons_basis_record_valid",
    "commons_character_supported",
    "action_links_are_real_paths",
    "private_locations_not_reconstructable",
    "location_precision_justified",
    "identity_is_unique",
    "publication_is_legally_and_privacy_acceptable",
    "next_review_date_set",
    "rejection_reason_structured_when_rejected"
  ],
  "commons_admission": {
    "definition_contract": "contracts/commonworld/commons-definition.contract.json",
    "basis_schema": "contracts/commonworld/commons-basis.schema.json",
    "basis_index": "catalog/commons-bases/index.json",
    "transition_effective_from": "2026-07-31",
    "retroreview_policy": "catalog/commons-bases/retroreview-policy.json",
    "include_requires_supported_dimensions": [
      "shared_resource",
      "community",
      "commoning_practice",
      "rules_and_responsibility",
      "common_benefit"
    ],
    "open_source_or_free_of_charge_alone_is_sufficient": false,
    "automatic_classification": false
  },
  "rejection_reason_codes": [
    "not_a_commons",
    "insufficient_sources",
    "duplicate",
    "private_location_risk",
    "commercial_listing_only",
    "project_inactive",
    "action_claim_unverified",
    "out_of_scope"
  ],
  "decision_record": {
    "structured_reason_required_for_rejection": true,
    "free_text_may_supplement": true,
    "reviewer_and_reviewed_at_required": true
  },
  "publication_boundary": {
    "proposal_is_not_catalog_record": true,
    "automatic_publication": false,
    "catalog_change_requires_reviewed_repository_commit": true,
    "published_record_must_validate_against": "contracts/commonworld/project.schema.json",
    "new_or_materially_rereviewed_record_must_have_commons_basis": true,
    "catalogued_at_set_on_first_publication": true,
    "catalogued_at_immutable_after_publication": true
  },
  "freshness": {
    "next_review_at_required_for_acceptance": true,
    "stale_entries_remain_explicit": true,
    "legacy_basis_review_uses_existing_next_review_at_with_migration_grace": true
  }
}